From Libertarian blogger at Political Culpa, Taylor A. Barnette, waxing sanctimony over Canada’s refusal to let Sun TV News (“Fox News North”) poison the airwaves as Fox has in his own country:
And so, while Canada might be a Fox-free, Michael Moore-approved Promised Land where healthcare flows like milk and honey, it certainly isn't free. I trust my fellow liberal Americans (excluding Kennedy) understand this. I trust that even though Fox (or Faux?) News might be the scourge of lefties everywhere, we can agree that its presence is healthier than its absence.
Much of the post is inane grandstanding devoid of logical argumentation, yet while that in itself isn’t worthy of a mention, I thought that last bit was just too savory. So, according to this latest radical Libertarian*, stopping an entity known for spreading little more than misinformation and smears, a group that (along with others like it) has successfully and thoroughly polluted the American political discourse, from going on the airwaves and knowingly, deliberately, spouting the same false crap here is unwarranted censorship. And in doing so, Canada is no longer “free”.
Okay, two little pointers. Firstly, censorship is when the government or similar authoritarian body prevents a person or group from speaking their minds as they see fit (as long as this does not fit under certain types of threats and criminal defamation, which I think everyone will agree are well beyond the pale for any sort of discourse). If Sun TV was not allowed to say things that, whilst true (or, at least, not knowingly false), somehow embarrassed the government, then that would be textbook censorship.
However, that is absolutely not the case, here. Sun TV is not being prevented from speaking their minds and sharing their opinions. It is being stopped from claiming things they know are bullshit to be news. One’s understanding of censorship and extents of free speech may vary, but anyone who honestly believes that people should be allowed to go on the air, knowingly and deliberately disseminate falsehoods, and escape all accountability for it, is someone with a very skewed, absolutist and frankly dangerous understanding of what “freedom” entails.